Steven Melia Steve.Melia@uwe.ac.uk
Senior Lecturer in Transport Planning
Do randomised control trials offer a solution to 'low quality' transport research?
Melia, Steve
Authors
Abstract
This article responds to Graham-Rowe et al. (2011), which categorised 77 evaluations of transport interventions into 5 levels of ‘quality’. This article focuses on Graham-Rowe et al.’s treatment of randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and their recommendation, also made by others, that RCTs should be used ‘wherever possible’ in transport research. It analyses the RCTs reviewed by Graham-Rowe et al. and the hierarchy of research methods they use. It proposes 5 criteria for the valid application of RCTs, which it argues would imply that the circumstances in transport studies where RCTs are demonstrably superior to other methods are very limited. It finds no valid justification for a hierarchy of methods and argues that attempting to apply such a hierarchy would generate misleading advice for policy makers.
Citation
Melia, S. (2015, January). Do randomised control trials offer a solution to 'low quality' transport research?. Paper presented at 47th Annual UTSG Conference
Presentation Conference Type | Conference Paper (unpublished) |
---|---|
Conference Name | 47th Annual UTSG Conference |
Start Date | Jan 5, 2015 |
End Date | Jan 7, 2015 |
Publication Date | Jan 1, 2015 |
Journal | Transportation Research Part A |
Print ISSN | 0965-8564 |
Peer Reviewed | Not Peer Reviewed |
Keywords | randomised control trials, voluntary travel behaviour change, modal shift, research methodology |
Publisher URL | http://www.utsg.net/web/index.php?page=annual-conference |
Additional Information | Title of Conference or Conference Proceedings : 47th Annual UTSG Conference |
Files
UTSG 2015 - Melia.pdf
(261 Kb)
PDF
You might also like
Pedestrianisation and politics: A case study
(2018)
Journal Article
Does transport investment really boost economic growth?
(2018)
Journal Article
What happens to travel behaviour when parking is removed?
(2017)
Presentation / Conference
Walking and cycling on shared-use paths: The user perspective
(2016)
Journal Article