Trade Union collective identity, mobilisation and leadership – a study of the printworkers’ disputes of 1980 and 1983

Costley, Nigel

Abstract

The National Graphical Association (NGA) typified the British model of craft unionism with substantial positional power and organisational strength. This study finds that it relied upon, and was reinforced by, the common occupational bonds that members identified with. It concludes that the value of collective identity warrants greater attention in the debate over union renewal alongside theories around mobilisation and organising (Kelly 2018), alliance-building and social movements (Holgate 2014).
Sectionalism builds solidarity through the exclusion of others. Occupational identity is vulnerable to technological change. This model neglects institutional and associational power, eschewing legal protections in favour of collective bargaining and ignoring alliance-building in favour of sovereign authority. The development of large conglomerate unions has placed membership unity over sectionalist solidarity but membership and its density in workplaces have fallen (Trade Union Statistics).
This thesis concludes that the capacity for strategic choice by union leaders depends upon the union’s leverage with employers and its ability to mobilise collective action within and beyond the workplace. These rely on strong collective identity of workers as demonstrated by the NGA in its 1980 national printing campaign.
The series of employment laws, launched in 1980, has constrained strategic options available to union leaders but the thesis argues that the technology and non-union labour rather than new laws were the critical factor in the NGA’s defeat in the 1983 Messenger dispute. The loss of positional power exposed the weakness of associational power when the NGA looked to the TUC and union allies for aid.
It argues that the forces that had made the union organisationally strong prevented it from taking alternative routes to survive or to transform itself in the face of fundamental technological change. Yet this should not lead union strategists from paying more attention to the value of sectional occupational identity in the mobilisation and organisation of workers.

Citation

Costley, N. Trade Union collective identity, mobilisation and leadership – a study of the printworkers’ disputes of 1980 and 1983. (Thesis). University of the West of England. Retrieved from https://uwe-repository.worktribe.com/output/6830037

• Thesis Type: Thesis
• Deposit Date: Nov 6, 2020
• Publicly Available Date: Aug 16, 2021
• Public URL: https://uwe-repository.worktribe.com/output/6830037
• Award Date: Aug 16, 2021